Skip to Main Content

Paperchase - BLUE TEAM: Task 3

Anatomy of a Legal Opinion

Caption Introductory material that usually includes the last names of the defendent and plaintiff. Ex. Roe v. Wade
Case citation The legal citation for the case; tells you the volume number, name of the case reporter, and page number it starts on. Ex. 685 N.E. 120; (volume 685, North Eastern reporter, page 120) Can also include parallel citations*
Author of the opinion The name of the judge who wrote the opinion. 
Facts of the case Summary of what happened; can include procedural history
Law of the case Often will discuss general principles of law and then discuss how those principles apply to the facts of the case
Concurring and/or dissenting opinions When a decision is not unanimous, a judge may offer concurring (where she agrees with the ruling, but for a different reason) or a dissenting (where she disagrees with the ruling) opinion

*Parallel citations are used when the same case is printed in two or more different reporters.  In other words, a parallel citation references location information for more than one source of a case. Look for parallel citations at the very top, often before the Caption.

Task Three : Anatomy of a Published Opinion

Find the following case and write its parallel citation on your worksheet:

599 N.E. 2d 913

If there is more than one parallel citation, chose one.